Deciding with ‘Dharma’: Lessons in Managerial Decision-Making and Ethical Leadership from the Panchatantra, Betaal Pachisi and Select Indian Tribal Literature (in Translation)

Authors

  • Arundhati Dinesh Mundhra Research Scholar, School of Liberal Arts and Culture Studies (SOLACS), Adamas University. Faculty at the Bhawanipur Education Society College, Kolkata.
  • Punyajit Gupta Assistant Professor, Department of English Language and Literature, Adamas University, Kolkata
  • Meghdoot Ghosh Professor, Post Graduate Institute of Hospital Administration, Peerless Hospital Campus, Kolkata

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.65525/prabandhan.v2i2.45

Keywords:

Ethical Leadership, Decision-Making, Indian Wisdom Traditions, Dharmic Management, Managerial Judgment

Abstract

King Vikramaditya must listen before each verdict and make a decision after each story; he is not allowed to evade, remain silent
or take a middle ground. Long before the case method came around in business schools, Indian minds had been honed to the art
of decisiveness and sound decision-making. This paper reads three such traditions side by side- the Panchatantra, Betaal Pachisi,
and some of the selected Indian tribal tales (in translation) and determines what they have to offer the modern manager in the
twin disciplines of ethical leadership and decision-making. The study takes a different path from the conventional reading of the
narratives as illustrations of existing management theory; it is a reading that starts with the narratives themselves, extracts the
decision logics contained within them, and then traces these to current management situations. Three different logics emerge:
the anticipatory logic and consequence-weighing strategy of the Panchatantra; the calculated reasoning under ambiguity
necessitated by Vikramaditya in the Betaal Pachisi; the consensual, stewardship-oriented decision-making of the tribal narratives, where the decision is made by the community itself. The binding of the three is ‘dharma’, not a strict moral rule but rather a situational compass, refusing to separate the 'smart' decision from the 'right' one. This is distilled in the paper into a three-lens model of ‘dharmic’ decision-making and illustrated with familiar managerial scenarios, which suggests that the stories are not mere parables to be admired but tools for developing judgment.

Downloads

Published

2026-10-09

How to Cite

Mundhra, A. D., Gupta, P., & Ghosh, M. (2026). Deciding with ‘Dharma’: Lessons in Managerial Decision-Making and Ethical Leadership from the Panchatantra, Betaal Pachisi and Select Indian Tribal Literature (in Translation). Prabandhan Darpan - Journal of Management Studies, 2(2), 56–69. https://doi.org/10.65525/prabandhan.v2i2.45